TY - JOUR
T1 - A study on the concept and characteristics of heritage impact assessments for cultural world heritage properties-focused on icomos guidance on heritage impact assessments and case reports-
AU - Kim, Chung Ho
AU - Kim, Dong Min
AU - Kim, Dong Min
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© 2020, Architectural Institute of Korea. All rights reserved.
PY - 2020/8
Y1 - 2020/8
N2 - This study aims to identify the concept and characteristics of Heritage Impact Assessments (HIA) in order to introduce and implement HIA in Korea. For this, the 2011 ICOMOS guidance on HIA and case reports were analyzed through the methods of document analysis and case study. As a result, the study reached the following five conclusions: First, HIA is an assessment system based on Outstanding Universal Value (OUV), using specific assessment items and methods drawn from each property and its proposed development. Second, HIA team as transparent and independent assessment agent has the authority to plan, conduct, and take the responsibility for HIA. Third, HIA assessment methods are derived and developed through consultation with relevant stakeholders. Fourth, HIA procedure consists two main stages such as scoping stage creating the scoping report and undertaking stage producing the HIA report. Fifth, mitigative measures and recommendations are proposed in order to avoid, reduce, and mitigate negative impacts of potential developments on OUV of properties. Finally, the study is expected to promote academic understanding and vibrant discussions for domestic introduction and smooth implementation of HIA.
AB - This study aims to identify the concept and characteristics of Heritage Impact Assessments (HIA) in order to introduce and implement HIA in Korea. For this, the 2011 ICOMOS guidance on HIA and case reports were analyzed through the methods of document analysis and case study. As a result, the study reached the following five conclusions: First, HIA is an assessment system based on Outstanding Universal Value (OUV), using specific assessment items and methods drawn from each property and its proposed development. Second, HIA team as transparent and independent assessment agent has the authority to plan, conduct, and take the responsibility for HIA. Third, HIA assessment methods are derived and developed through consultation with relevant stakeholders. Fourth, HIA procedure consists two main stages such as scoping stage creating the scoping report and undertaking stage producing the HIA report. Fifth, mitigative measures and recommendations are proposed in order to avoid, reduce, and mitigate negative impacts of potential developments on OUV of properties. Finally, the study is expected to promote academic understanding and vibrant discussions for domestic introduction and smooth implementation of HIA.
KW - Case Study
KW - Document Analysis
KW - Heritage Impact Assessment
KW - ICOMOS Guidance
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85102804793&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.5659/JAIK.2020.36.8.61
DO - 10.5659/JAIK.2020.36.8.61
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85102804793
SN - 2733-6239
VL - 36
SP - 61
EP - 72
JO - Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea
JF - Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea
IS - 8
ER -