Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Measuring Vowel Contrast Revisited

  • University of Seoul

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

Abstract

This study revisits the measurement of vowel contrast by evaluating the Pillai score with a sample-size-adjusted threshold (P95) as a categorical criterion. We examined the assumption that vowels are contrastive when the Pillai score exceeds the P95 threshold as derived from the Stanley and Sneller (2023)’s contrapositive. Six adjacent English vowel pairs (/i–ɪ/, /ɛ–æ/, /u–ʊ/, /ɑ–ɔ/, /ɑ–ʌ/, /ɔ–ʌ/) produced by 36 native speakers in two speech corpora were analyzed through MANOVA on normalized F1, F2, and duration. Pillai scores of six vowel pairs were calculated for each speaker and then converted to binary values (Pbin), coded as 1 if the score exceeded P95 and 0 otherwise. Results showed that /i–ɪ/ and /ɑ–ʌ/ consistently exceeded the threshold across all speakers, while the /u–ʊ/ pair exhibited the lowest rate of threshold achievement as found in 27 out of 36. This indicates that 27 native speakers did not produce these vowels contrastively, reflecting unstable phonemic status of the /u–ʊ/ pair. Logistic regression confirmed that all vowel pairs were significantly more likely to yield Pbin =1. We concluded that native speakers tend to produce vowel pairs contrastively, although some speakers exhibited merged productions for certain pairs. The application of the Pillai score with its P95 threshold to vowel contrast analysis provides a unified criterion for assessing vowel contrasts in English. This approach could be further applied in L2 contexts to eliminate the need for direct native-speaker comparison.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)275-285
Number of pages11
JournalKorean Journal of English Language and Linguistics
Volume26
DOIs
StatePublished - 2026

Keywords

  • MANOVA
  • Pillai
  • Threshold
  • vowel contrast

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Measuring Vowel Contrast Revisited'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this